Thursday, March 23, 2006

"God or the Girl": reality tv's cry for help or an all-time low?

while flipping through the channels today, i came across a segment on Entertainment Tonight that was featuring a sneak-peak of a new reality tv show called God or the Girl - conveniently set to air on Easter weekend.

five young men in their 20s (who appropriately enough, *just happen* to be good-looking) must decide between serving in the priesthood or living a life free to date and mingle with girls - the gist of the show is to follow them through a series of days and "trials" that are supposed to help sway them towards making *the* decision, of which the final verdict will be declared on national tv at the end of the show's duration.

now, sure; i admit that i do enjoy watching reality tv every so often and allow myself to be sucked into the craziness (and perhaps stupidity) of it all. but c'mon now - does anyone else find this particular concept even the least bit disturbing and just plain... weird? has reality tv actually come to the point where they've finally run out of ideas - i mean, i thought the train unofficially made its final stop at MTV's Surreal World - yeesh, i guess i was wrong.

one clip that i found particularly uncomfortable to watch was of one of the guys who felt that he had to serve his penance by carrying a life-size wooden cross on his back while travelling 80 miles on foot as a result of his guilt for lusting over a girl at one point in his life; unworthy because of the things he had done in the past - and meanwhile, he had his own coaching squad guiding him through the long trek as if his very life depended on it.

after watching that 5-minute preview, i just felt really... sad - not only for him, but for the possible reactions that could potentially evolve from this show. though some viewers could take this show "seriously", others could and probably will consider this show as the punchline to their daily conversations. and what doesn't help much at all is that this is the type of thing that usually feeds into into all of the negative views and stereotypes that people have towards religion, especially with regards to Christianity/Catholicism.

perhaps i'm being bias to this whole thing due to the idealogies my own spiritual upbringing has instilled in me, but maybe - just maybe - reality tv has gone a little too far with this one.

by the way, has anyone had a chance to watch passions in the past couple of days? apparently whitney saw God in the chapel of her convent, who she claims told her to brutally flog herself in order to pay penance for her sins of committing incest with her half-brother, chad.

and with that, i leave a resounding OY.

5 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

and just when i thought that "who's your daddy" was the all-time low for tv in general, a new challenger emerges...

glad i don't get home in time to watch anything. but it seems that i'm not missing much of anything.

March 27, 2006 9:54 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Tsk tsk tsk - whatever happened to my loveable panda wife? judge not unless you have all the facts.

People out there have wierd and horribly wrong views - and from what Ive seen and read - which btw as you know the preview is NOT a good source from which to judge anything. The show while it looks stupid, has its place.

Sheeesh - Remember there are people out there who believe Satan is stronger then God vis a vis generational curses. Who blame mommy and daddy for their shortcomings.

There are far FAR more important things to worry about then a show you havent even seen yet; and may or may not turn out to be detrimental to someone's faith. Because surprisingly Im actually looking forward to the show, and Doctor Who is far more important anyways!

Oh yeah and Im back in Canada now.

March 29, 2006 3:16 AM  
Blogger mags said...

Hi Estelle, it's me Tet! I couldn't help but comment - that show's for real? I think it's a bit too much to have a reality show based on religion only because it is poor in taste. Oh well, that's just me... :-) Hope you're doing great.

April 06, 2006 4:45 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

God or the Girl is not a Reality Show. It is a documentary. I think you will find that the Title does not reflect the show. I have seen it and it is very powerful.

Give it a chance.

April 07, 2006 1:31 AM  
Blogger mamastella said...

hmmm. yes, i realize that my perspective on this show was most likely skewed by the hyped-up preview that ET gave out. but documentary or not, even though it may have its share of positive aspects and have its appropriate place in the wonderful world of television; it's rather unfortunate that such things as misleading previews and titles can cheapen its value on the whole.

... knowing me of course, regardless of what i think about it, i will probably find myself watching it anyway just to put my own curiosity to rest :oP

April 08, 2006 10:54 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home